The Iron Law of 5.5%
Risk-free cash now pays 5.5% a year. That is the bar every other investment has to clear after risk. This week, the arithmetic that breaks the private credit pitch, the property market that keeps falling, and the rare earth exit ban you have not heard about.
Risk Free
Lowest Ever
Below Cash
One Developer
There is an iron law of investing, and almost no one talks about it. It is called opportunity cost. It asks a single question. What did you give up by putting your money into A instead of B?
Right now, cash pays around 5.5%. That is close to risk free. And that number changes everything.
The VAS ETF, which tracks the ASX 300, delivers an earnings yield of about 4.5% to 5%, but strip out the capital growth portion and the actual dividend yield is roughly 3%. In other words, the "safe income" from Australian shares is now running about 250 basis points below what cash pays.
The US market is worse. The S&P 500 dividend yield now sits at 1.03%, the lowest ever recorded. Investors buying US shares today are accepting almost no yield in return for taking full equity risk on the most expensive market in 155 years.
Then there is the sudden avalanche of private credit offerings quoting 7.5% and even 8% paid monthly, all over LinkedIn and every finance publication in the country. Almost no one is talking about the risk sitting underneath those returns …
… most of that private credit is lent against real estate. Which is exactly what the news headlines say is breaking. A single Sydney developer now has more than $3 billion in debt tied to 18 private credit funds, and the excerpt we cover this week shows why the 2% premium over cash can melt in a heartbeat …
… the full dividend yield instrument panel: US 1.03%, ASX 3%, cash 5.5%, and what the arithmetic actually says about where returns come from over the next decade …
… the rare earth chapter: China's new formal exit ban on scientists takes effect September 15, why the West is now stuck with an ageing knowledge base, and the one Western position we hold that changes if this plays out …
… plus the Weekly Video Review, this week's Stock Watch full analysis, and the Anti-Fragile Investor whitepaper for members to download and keep …
The full Members Message on opportunity cost, the 5.5% rule, and how to run every pitch through the risk-free number
The Weekly Video Review with Steve, Tom and Jacob on camera, walking through the week's positioning
The three points of friction: the Saudi Aramco commentary on the oil supply shock, China's exit ban, and the private credit story now front-page news
The Oz Economy read: the RBA on hold, the housing slump spreading into 97% of Sydney suburbs, and what it means for the collateral behind private credit
The dividend yield instrument panel: US, ASX and cash side by side, with the historic reads underneath
The Stock Watch: our full analysis of the one Western position we hold on this week's theme, including the staged allocation framework
The Anti-Fragile Investor whitepaper, ready to download, keep and re-read
Opportunity cost is the discipline. Every pitch, every stock, every fund gets run through 5.5%. If it does not clear the bar after risk, it does not go in the portfolio.
This week's episode walks through the same themes you have just read: the 5.5% question, the private credit warnings, the property market's next leg down, and how the Aramco commentary changes the oil picture. Free listeners get the full episode.
Opportunity cost is a numbers game. Sticking to it, in a market that keeps waving 7.5% in your face, is a discipline game. That starts with knowing your own wiring. Our free investor personality assessment, built on the Enneagram framework, takes ten minutes and shows you your archetype, your strengths, and the blind spots that cost you money.
The full weekly issue, monthly live coaching calls with Steve, Tom and Jacob, the TMM Learning Hub, the Weekly Video Review, the Anti-Fragile Investor whitepaper, and every Stock Watch analysis. The average financial adviser charges around $7,000 a year. This is $9.99 a week, and you keep the knowledge forever.
This newsletter is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.
Total Money Management | AFSL 568642