Being Too Early Is Indistinguishable From Being Wrong
Market tops are a process, not a point. Why the contrarian looks foolish before being right, and what that means for where you sit today.
One aspect of being a contrarian investor is making what appears to be an incorrect call on markets when they become expensive. When markets reach "the top," we imagine a single point. But a market peak is usually a process, and it may take six to twelve months before the fall actually begins. Up until that point, you look like a fool as markets climb higher, and folks take the time to let you know it. Especially those making hay while the sun shines.
During the falling process, which can be sudden like 2008, or take a few years like 2000 to 2003, or slower still like 1965 to 1982, markets stage what are called bear market rallies, and some are substantial. They happened in 1929, 1973, 2000 and 2008. What made those declines different was that markets were in secular, not cyclical, bear markets, the aftermath of extreme overvaluation following years of above-average returns. Think of everything since the March 2009 low. Alas, it always comes to an end. And the winners are the investors who understand that …
… markets can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent, so the game is never picking the top. It is being positioned before the decline arrives and knowing what conditions mark the bottom. This week's full issue maps the whole framework: the three points of friction in geopolitics, the Australian price-to-income ratio now at double its historical average and fifty percent above the US …
… the CAPE instrument panel at 41.6 with an implied return of 1.8% a year for a decade, and the full Japan study: the highest CAPE ever recorded, the twenty-year decline that followed, and the four giant bear market rallies of 44% to 137% that fooled buy-and-hold investors every single time …
… plus why commodities and emerging markets are where we want to be positioned, and the special podcast roundtable on Howard Marks' Mastering the Market Cycle with the full show notes document …
The full Members Message on being early, the Keynes rule, and why we would rather look foolish now than be broke later
The Australian property instrument: price-to-income recreated state by state, Sydney at nearly 14 years of income, and the AUS vs US divergence chart since 2000
The CAPE panel at 41.6, second-highest reading in 155 years, implied return 1.8% a year for the next decade
The Japan study: the TOPIX lost decades recreated, four bear market rallies of 44% to 137%, and why "time in the market" fails from extreme valuations
The three points of friction: Iran and the Strait, property's panic button, and the margin debt build-up
The Mastering the Market Cycle show notes: the complete companion document to this week's special podcast
The names we are actually positioned around. Not hints. The calls themselves, and the thinking behind every one.
The peak is a process. So is preparation. The investors who do well through what follows will be the ones positioned before it arrives, not after.
This week Steve, Tom and Jacob sit down with one book and work through it properly: Howard Marks' Mastering the Market Cycle. The psychology pendulum, the three stages of bull and bear markets, and what it means for how you position right now. Free listeners get the full episode.
Marks says the superior investor is mature, rational, analytical, objective and unemotional. That starts with knowing your own wiring. Our free investor personality assessment, built on the Enneagram framework, takes ten minutes and shows you your archetype, your strengths, and the blind spots that cost you money.
The full weekly issue, monthly live coaching calls with Steve, Tom and Jacob, the TMM Learning Hub, the members video and every show notes document. The average financial adviser charges around $7,000 a year. This is $9.99 a week, and you keep the knowledge forever.
This newsletter is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.
Total Money Management | AFSL 568642