Signals & Noise — Free Edition | May 8, 2026
Total Money Management
Trust & Integrity
Free Edition

Week Ending May 8, 2026
Signals & Noise
Weekly market thinking for long-term investors
Looking for previous editions? Signals & Noise Archive →

Time in the Market vs Timing the Market

"It's time in the market, not timing the market." You have heard it a thousand times. It is the most repeated piece of advice in the financial industry. It is also, on the current numbers, demonstrably wrong.

One trait that separates investors who succeed from those who fail is the willingness to change perspective when the evidence demands it. Most investors do the opposite. They cling to a belief, search desperately for counter-arguments to defend it, and refuse to update even when the maths stops adding up.

So for those who still believe time in the market always works, here is what you are up against right now. The S&P 500 dividend yield is 1.5%. That is a P/E of 66. The earnings yield is 3.22%, lower than bonds. Cash beats US equity earnings yield. That has not been true in a generation. Howard Marks recently spoke about the one number that guarantees you won't make money: when the S&P 500 has historically traded above CAPE 23, the next 10 years have delivered roughly zero in annualised returns. The CAPE is now 31. The Buffett Indicator is at 231% in the US, against Australia's 96%, and the gap between the two countries on every valuation measure is the widest it has been in …

… over two decades. The implications for portfolio construction are significant. When risk-free assets pay more than risky ones, the entire framework for asset allocation needs to flip. We have been running the numbers across 14 different scenarios and the conclusions are consistent: the traditional 60/40 has become …

Steve has spent this week unpacking exactly what this means for your positioning, including the specific sectors that historically outperform when CAPE is this elevated, the bond yield arithmetic that no advisor will tell you about, and the four indicators we are watching for …

Premium Members Only

Want the rest? Premium subscribers received the full edition this morning, including Steve's expected returns table, the Buffett Indicator deep dive, the Howard Marks scatter chart, and four more special topics.


You Are Reading the Free Edition
Get the Full Edition Free for 2 Weeks
Members get the complete weekly review: Steve's full geopolitics and economy analysis, Buffett deep dives, sector breakdowns, the members-only video, and our portfolio thinking.
⏰ Limited Time Promo
Try Premium Free for 14 Days
No card required upfront. Cancel anytime before the trial ends and pay nothing.
$9.99 per week
Free for 2 Weeks
Start Your Free Trial →
No charge for 14 days. Cancel anytime. $9.99/week after trial.